How to Write an Autobiography and Prevent Yourself From Getting Sued
Writer Anne Lamott said, "If people wanted you to write warmly about them, they should have behaved better." She has a point -- but legally, it's complicated. If what you are telling is your own true story, chances are good that a court would uphold your right to tell it. That said, avoiding court in the first place is better yet. Before you attempt to publish an autobiography, arm yourself with a basic understanding of the laws about defamation and invasion of privacy.
Defamation of character is the legal term for publishing libel -- false statements about an identifiable person that cause harm to his reputation. If you can prove your facts to be true, you're not liable for defamation. To win a defamation suit, the claimant would need to prove that what you wrote is false and that it has harmed his reputation. For example, if you write in your autobiography that Joe's Diner is a grease pit with health department problems, and Joe can produce evidence that it isn't true and that business has gotten worse because of your book, he may have a case. Opinion, however, is not considered libel. You could repeat, "I hated the home fries at Joe's" in every chapter and be on safe legal ground.
Avoiding Invasion of Privacy
Legally actionable invasion of privacy occurs when you disclose information about an identifiable individual that is previously unknown, factual and not newsworthy. Famous people are considered generally newsworthy. You may know that your former boss beat her husband, but telling the world -- unless she is famous or was convicted of it in court -- is a bad idea. If, on the other hand, she used to beat you, you are considered an interested party and the story is yours to tell; she may still sue, but is unlikely to prevail.
The New York Times best-seller list memoir "Running With Scissors" includes graphic depictions of extreme child abuse. The Turcotte family sued author Augusten Burroughs and St. Martin's Press for both defamation and invasion of privacy. Family members said the writer was fabricating and exaggerating. The case was settled out of court when Burroughs paid an undisclosed amount of money and agreed to acknowledge in future editions that the Turcottes remembered things differently, that he meant them no harm, and that he and his publisher were sorry for any unintentional harm done to them. Many memoirs contain similar disclaimers, pointing out that parts of a book are "reconstructed from memory," or that some identities have been disguised, and unless you have carried a tape recorder with you at all times, this may be a good idea.
If it hadn't been clear that the Finches in "Running With Scissors" were based on the Turcottes of Northhampton, Massachusetts, Burroughs could not have been sued. The plaintiff in a defamation or invasion of privacy suit needs to prove that readers can easily figure out who the author is talking about. Just changing a name or a physical description may not be enough to protect you against a claim if other details make it obvious who you are writing about.
The Bottom Line
The definitions of defamation of character and invasion of privacy, unlike many laws, are somewhat subjective. No matter how careful you are, if you're writing about anything controversial, the possibility exists that someone may feel defamed or invaded. Telling the truth, avoiding gratuitous insults, respecting the privacy of the innocent and acknowledging your own fallibility is the best course. If you're working with a publisher, the company's legal team will examine your manuscript for possible problems. If you are self publishing, consider having your work vetted by a professional editor or an attorney who specializes in these issues.
- WritersDigest.com: A Writer’s Guide to Defamation and Invasion of Privacy
- HelenSedwick.com: How To Use Real People In Your Writing
- The Law Dictionary.org: How Do You Prove a Defamation of Character Claim? Law Dictionary: How Do You Prove a Defamation of Character Claim?
- Rights of Writers: Can You Tell Your Own True Story Even If It Impinges on the Privacy of Your Lovers, Friends, and Family?
- New York Magazine: Arts: Books: The Memory Addict
- VanityFair.com: Ruthless with "Scissors"
- USAToday.com: Life: Books: Burroughs Settles Lawsuit with "Scissors" Family
Anne Pyburn Craig has written for a range of regional and local publications ranging from in-depth local investigative journalism to parenting, business, real estate and green building publications. She frequently writes tourism and lifestyle articles for chamber of commerce publications and is a respected book reviewer.